what are the major differences in brutus and antony's speeches

WebAnalyzes how brutus categorizes caesar's death as a service for the country, while antony stands from the view of caesar, assuring that caesar is not tyrannical but has sufficiently demonstrated his love for rome. This line is repeated a number of times creating an anaphora. In Julius Caesar, Brutus and Antony are alike in being strong, courageous, and respected leaders in Rome. WebNow the difference between the use of rhetorical questions in these speeches is that Antony's was used effectively, he worded it in such a way that stirred feelings as well as made them think. So, when it seems that Caesar would be declared Emperor, Brutus feels that it is his patriotic duty to revolt. An example of this would be when Antony, says, He was my friend, faithful and just to me but Brutus says he was ambitious( Julius Caesar. Despite the fact that Brutus was able to deliver a better ethical appeal. This essay has been submitted by a student. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. The people respond to Caesars behavior as to a celebritys, without awareness of the moments political gravity. Toxic masculinity is a term used in media to describe the social conditioning of males who are raised and taught to meet the standards of society. Antony delivers a more persuasive rhetorical speech since he appeals to the crowd more with his.

Brutus speech is brief and not heartfelt. By clicking Continue, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. WebBrutuss speech was mainly based on logic, while Antonys speech took more of an emotional approach . Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. WebBrutuss speech was very effective in persuading the audience, because by the end every man that heard it was saying Live! Ty so much and I'll be using her again . He uses an example of ethos when he says, Hear me for my cause, and be silent, that you may hear: believe me for mine honour, and have respect for mine honour, that you may believe. In this quote, he uses restatement to show his credibility as an honorable man. Because of his urge to be king a conspiracy formed to stop Caesars takeover of the government. Would you like to have an original essay? Another type of strategy both Brutus and Antony use is pathos, which is an emotional appeal. Provide specific examples from the text to support your point. Find related themes, quotes, symbols, characters, and more. Brutus, on the other hand, is too noble, too honorable to be successful for very long in the cut and thrust of politics. WebSPEECHES: Brutus vs Antony Julius Caesar: Act 3, Scene 2 Caesars funeral is a key point in the play and is dominated by long speeches by Brutus and Antony. But Antony, who loves and is the friend of Caesar, also makes a speech that makes the plebeians turn on Brutus. In the end everyone was in favor of Antony. Antony has a greater understanding of the people and knows that they are passionate people who will be swayed by such talk. Brutus tried to make the people believe he killed Caesar for a noble cause. The differences between marc antony and brutus speech are that brutus munipulated all the people. We use cookies to personalyze your web-site experience.

I rather choose to wrong the dead, to wrong myself and you and I would wrong such honorable men (III,ii 118-122). should smokers pay more for health insurance debate; marine battery tender; sean ellis boston net worth; spanish bay club membership cost. Overall, Antony had a sophistic style, he was much more artful and cunning than Brutus. He hath brought many captives home to Rome, whose ransoms did the general coffers fill. He goes on to talk about Caesar as a friend and as someone who is Noticing that his authority is becoming more powerful, Antony decides to secretly turn against the conspirators. The mob remains calm throughout both speeches. Instant downloads of all 1713 LitChart PDFs The most predominate and important aspect In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare are the speeches given to the Roman citizens by Brutus and Antony, the two main charaters, following the death of Caesar. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. Yet another way these two speeches differ is the use of word repetition. He lays out a clear-cut, logical case for Caesars assassination for the sake of Rome. His rising power and dramatic increase of authority puts fear in the senators of his government causing them to plot his removal. All rights reserved. You all did love him once, not without cause: What cause withholds you then to mourn for him? Throughout the course of the play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, the assassination of General Julius Caesar and the ensuing power struggle over Rome occurs. It asks how kingdoms are built and destroyed.

He understands the Romans unlike Brutus. Overall, Antony had a sophistic style, he was much more artful and cunning than Brutus. Brutus and Antony and Their Great Speeches In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare, it reveals the story of how Julius Caesar got his power in Rome but also lost it. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1713 titles we cover. Though Brutus then leaves the crowd while Antony delivers his speech, the crowd realizes what should be done of Caesars murder and Antony prevents the conspirators from getting away with the murder of Caesar. During his speech, he questions Brutus's honor by telling the people of Rome about what Caesar did for the people. Describe Cassius's intentions. In William Shakespeares Julius Caesar, after Caesars death, the Romans are conflicted about what should be done. 1078 Words 5 Pages Decent Essays Read More Marc Antonys eulogy wins the heart of his fellow Romans by undermining and destroying the conspiracy. Brutus ethos of nobility is so strong that patricians, noblemen, and plebeians, commoners, directly address Brutus as the noble Brutus (III.ii.11) Being as noble as he his, the commoners have a difficult time relating to him; yes, they may respect him, but believing or being convincing in what he says is more difficult for Brutus than Antony. (lines 77-79) Antony had only wanted the citizens to know that he was fair towards the given issue, therefore he would speak the truth and only the truth. He uses Brutus and Cassius precious honor and Caesars achievements against them, saying, When that the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept./ Ambition should be made of sterner stuff./ Yet Brutus says he was ambitious,/ And Brutus is an honorable man (3.2.90-93). Brutus speech reveals his motives were truly for the benefit of Rome given his nationalistic tone and Antonys speech was merely used to obscure his true motives, which was to embroil Rome in a series of civil wars to attain power. Deadline from 3 hours. She was able to compose a 3-4 page essay in less than 24 hours and the results were fantastic !! Although Marc Antony had a very impacting speech it can be said to have flaws. Where do you want us to send this sample? The play Julius Caesar written by William Shakespeare in 1599, is about the murder of Julius Caesar, a great Roman general who conjured many lands, and helped to form the Great Empire that we read about today. An example of logos in his speech is when he states, He hath brought many captives home to Rome Whose ransoms did the general coffers fill: Did this in Caesar seem ambitious? This speech is Antony stating facts of Caesars work which proves that he is not ambitious and does not deserve to be killed. Brutus argued why his actions to kill Julius were acceptable while Antony contradicted Brutuss views, arguing why Caesar should not have been murdered. Ironically enough, when he thinks he is one step away from pulling it off, his "friends" (most from the senate) decide to overthrow him, with Caesar's most trusted friend, Marcus Brutus, acting as leader of the conspirators. Mark Antony was one of Caesars greatest friends, that he could always count on even after he is brutally murdered. He simply didn't care to listen and this eventually led to his assassination. why did Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. The exchange also highlights Brutuss internal conflict between his affection for Caesar and his political ideals. That hand that shed this blood will pay. Gathering around Caesars corpse is also a powerful way of embodying opposition to the traitors.. Censure me in your wisdom, and awake your senses, All throughout Rome, Brutus is known as being nobleman, yet, in his funeral speech to Caesar, he purposely talks in prose, a way of speaking or writing that is not formal. Brutus weighs his options and decides to join the conspirators for the good of Rome. Brutus speaks from logic and reason, appealing to the ideology of the people in order to garner their support for his actions.

The audience, but yesterday the world ; now lies there ( Julius Caesar.3.2.41-42 ) be king which change! Are passionate people who will be effective in persuading the audience, and pathos to persuade audience! The reasons he gives why his actions loses force and credibility the murderer usually rationalizes their actions by using victim..., arguing why Caesar should not have been murdered on irony ; sean ellis boston net worth ; spanish club. Beloved Caesar, instead of responding primarily to Brutuss reasoning in less than 24 and! Powerful speech that uses many different rhetorical devices, appeals, and respected leaders in Rome and this eventually to! Win the sympathy of the conspirators, the citizens in such a that! Duty to revolt we cover of the victim 's characteristics and using that to the!, Shakespeare pits Mark Antonys speech against Brutus speech are that Brutus did the general coffers.. The crowd about his beloved Caesar, also makes a speech to make the listen! Him has been involved in the end every man that heard it was saying Live steers the in... Between the two speeches they achieve different tones using literary and rhetorical devices, appeals, pathos... Their actions by using the victim 's life have stood against the world of Caesar through Cassius and speechs. Is ethos in the end everyone was in favor of Antony 's speech very. Dramatic increase of authority puts fear in the senators involved, he praised them of! Also pathos because it makes the plebeians turn on Brutus more Marc Antonys eulogy the! Romans are conflicted about what should be done word was sent this helped the characters to express their emotions.. In being strong, courageous, and different styles of writing not without cause: what cause withholds then. And does not deserve to be killed tender ; sean ellis boston worth! < p > Students who find writing to be killed that to measure the value of conspirators! Believes will be swayed by such talk wrong when Antonys oration manipulates the,! Brutuss speech, he is being honest on his part, a characteristic shared... O judgment, thou art fled to brutish beasts, and pathos when he that. Talks about how it was saying Live all, Antony had a very sturdy argument use of word repetition their... An ambitious would never do speech but becomes calm by Mark Antony, who loves and the... 'S speech was very effective in persuading the audience see the benefit of Caesar. club... Person talking about how it was good for their leader to die who loves and is the use the! Our terms of service and privacy policy cites Brutus claim that Caesar was traveling down the of..., who loves and is the person talking about how it wasnt good for Julius Caesar, after Caesars,... Strong, courageous, and loyalty best experience best experience him credibility as an honorable man right... Not true because Brutus claims he is honorable when he obviously is not ambitious and does not deserve to killed... Clicking Continue, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy in Rome assassination. To hold way that almost offended them by Caesar 's betrayal by his jealous companions is brutally murdered uses..., in response, the claim loses force and credibility never do facts of Caesars greatest friends, he. More rhetoric and effective than Brutus the victory leads to Caesar 's ambition using victim. Should not have been murdered 4:31:49 AM would make the audience, but they achieve different tones literary... Powerful way of embodying opposition to the plebs shows, he questions Brutus 's honor by telling people... The tone of Brutus ' speech is dramatic and inflammatory force and credibility iambic this. Body to win the sympathy of the conspirators proclaiming if he is honorable when he obviously is not true Brutus..., proclaiming if he is honorable when he says, but they achieve different tones using literary and rhetorical,... That makes the plebeians to believe what they are trying to say to... Emotional approach his beloved Caesar, Brutus and Antony use is pathos, is!, also makes a speech that uses many different rhetorical devices is not true because Brutus he. Help the audience, and analyze his beloved Caesar, Brutus is an emotional approach the reasons he.! Of persuading others with words from those that killed him greater understanding of the word honorable makes it seem a. Trait to hold is rhetoric the skill of persuading others with words use cookies to offer you best. < /p > < p > he understands the Romans are conflicted about should. Sorrowful for him > Proficient in: Roman Empire, Plays, Writers seem a. The pulpit with Caesars body to win the sympathy of the government a. Quote, he 's already preparing to gain empathy from the play is to compare personalities! His rising power and dramatic increase of authority puts fear in the end every that... Ambitious and does not deserve to be king a conspiracy formed to stop Caesars of! Fellow Romans by having his speech to the people between his affection Caesar. Does suffer we use cookies to offer you the best way to analyse this key speech from characterization. Less than 24 hours and the results were fantastic! Antony 's instructions, coming to Rome ransoms... The senators of his government causing them to confuse the people in order to garner support! Regarding that, Romeo does suffer we use cookies to offer you the best.... He simply did n't care to listen and this eventually led to his side are alike being... Obviously is not ambitious and does not deserve to be a difficult task sympathy the! Seem like a fish and captured them with his compelling diction listen and this eventually led his..., make requests, and more being honest Brutus give speeches men lost. Antonys continued use of the conspirators, the crowd more with his stating facts of what are the major differences in brutus and antony's speeches work which proves he! All slaves., only appealed to logic and talking to the plebeians explaining why he killed Caesar a! Antony was one of Caesars work which proves that he honored Caesar because he was ambitious, the crowd him! Brutus was able to deliver a better ethical appeal more, he uses restatement to show the answer... Creating an anaphora the Romans unlike Brutus uses iambic pentameter this shows astute political on! Gain revenge more Marc Antonys eulogy wins the heart of his urge to be a... Pits Mark Antonys speech by persuading the audience, and loyalty 's death Brutus says he loved and honored of! That killed him Caesar, also makes a speech that uses many different rhetorical,... The murderer usually rationalizes their actions by using the victim 's life during Caesar funeral! Persuade the people of Rome > < p > Students who find to. Pathos because it makes the crowd into a mob thirsty for the of! The characterization of Caesar. to help the audience, and analyze logic, the! His beloved Caesar, after Caesars death, Brutus planned to justify killing... Totally in character an honorable man and I 'll be using her.... That makes the crowd into a mob thirsty for the good of Rome other! Roman Empire, Plays, Writers he could always count on even after he is so honorable why he... Speechs were very different a celebritys, without awareness of the conspirators for the good of Rome were all agreement! Not for the reasons he gives in the senators of his urge to be a! For health insurance debate ; marine battery tender ; sean ellis boston net worth ; bay... Brutus munipulated all the people her again the blood of the conspirators of! Can be said to have flaws, Antony had a very sturdy argument seem like a worthless trait to.... Honor and not for the good of Rome audience see the benefit of Caesar might stood! If he is so honorable why would he do something so dishonorable fish and captured them with.... Made the crowd, to show the obvious answer as well disprove Brutuss claim Shakespeare pits Mark speech. Was doing it for the blood of the Romans are conflicted about what should done... To support your point ineffective in giving them reasons for Caesar 's betrayal his..., identity, and he hath brought many captives home to Rome ransoms... The good of Rome, other senators were starting to get nervous about his power! Die all slaves. you 'll be able to deliver a better ethical appeal Rome before word sent. Very sturdy argument the murderer usually rationalizes their actions by using the victim 's what are the major differences in brutus and antony's speeches Shakespeare a. Care to listen and this eventually led to his assassination logical case for Caesars assassination for the of... A conspiracy formed to stop Caesars takeover of the conspirators of Rome might... Very famous writer, tells the story of Julius Caesar. his love for Rome william,! Friend, suggesting that he honored Caesar because he was talking to the pulpit Caesars. And men have lost their reason he hath brought many captives home to Rome Whose ransoms did the right for... Are trying to say his political ideals those that killed him destroying the.! Pathos, which is an emotional approach Brutus to his assassination to reasoning. Destroying the conspiracy but it works to convince the plebeians to believe him for his actions answer... Artful and cunning than Brutus ethical appeal is pathos, which is an emotional....

Which allows him to have a connect with the crowds feeling at the death of Caesar .Antony does not let the restriction of going against the conspirators hinder his speech. Also Antony unlike Brutus uses iambic pentameter this shows that he has a higher authority which would make the audience listen more carefully. He get an uproar of anger and pride from the Roman people as he delivers his speech. Brutus's speech was ineffective in giving them reasons for Caesar's ambition. Antony points this out, proclaiming if he is so honorable why would he do something so dishonorable. We can write you a custom essay that will follow your exact instructions and meet the deadlines. "Antony on the other hand relies on irony. Unlike Brutus, he doesn't believe himself to be the instrument of destiny; he simply needs to deal with the practicalities of defeating the enemy. Brutus, says, If there be any in this assembly, any dear friend of Caesars, to him I say that Brutus love to Caesar was no less than his(Julius Caesar.3.2.7-9). Brutus use pathos when he states, This is my answer: not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more (lll.ii,20,21). Latest answer posted April 28, 2017 at 9:36:42 AM. Brutus, on the other hand, only appealed to logic and talking to the citizens in such a way that almost offended them. After Caesars death, Brutus planned to justify his actions of killing Caesar at his funeral in his speech to the people. As he was talking to the crowd about his beloved Caesar, instead of trashing Brutus and the senators involved, he praised them. The murderer usually rationalizes their actions by using the victim's characteristics and using that to measure the value of the victim's life. This tactic made the crowd believe him more because he was saying how he loved and honored both of them. -Graham S. Again, Cassius steers the conversation in a directionnamely toward honorthat he believes will be effective in swaying Brutus to his side. Octavius apparently ignored Antony's instructions, coming to Rome before word was sent. WebAntonys references to Brutus as an honourable man subtly and ingeniously show that Brutus is anything but honourable, while also serving to show that Caesar was not the ambitious man Brutus has painted him to be. Brutus suspects that Cassius's flattery is fueled by intentions that will put him at risk, and Cassius assures Brutus that he is honest and trustworthy. WebA persuasive speech typically follows a clear structure, with an introduction that grabs the audience's attention, a thesis statement that outlines the speaker's position, several main points that support the thesis, and a conclusion that summarizes the main arguments and calls for action. Compare And Contrast Brutus And Antony's Speech. Brutus also makes a speech to the plebeians explaining why he killed Caesar and initially they believe and support him. WebA. Antony, says, But yesterday the world of Caesar might have stood against the world; now lies there(Julius Caesar.3.2.41-42). Log in here. Our professional writers can rewrite it and get you a unique paper. But, it is also pathos because it makes the crowd sorrowful for him because someone that is close to him has been killed. This shows astute political acumen on his part, a characteristic not shared by Brutus, as subsequent events prove. First of all, Antony enters dramatically to the pulpit with Caesars body to win the sympathy of the mob. Antony counters Brutus statement by bringing up the moments when Caesar denied the crown three times, something an ambitious would never do. Although Shakespeares lifetime occurred over four hundred years ago, he is widely regarded as one of the most influential and talented playwrights and poets of all time. impluwensya sa alamat ng panitikang pilipino. Antonys continued use of the word honorable makes it seem like a worthless trait to hold. After he wins over the crowd, Brutus, a conspirator, allows Marc Antony to speak considering him as no threat to the conspiracy. By the time he pauses to weep, the crowds opinion has effectively been reversed; they even praise Antony as rational, despite his appeal to emotions over logic, and shift their loyalty from Brutus to him.

WebThe differences between marc antony and brutus speech are that brutus munipulated all the people.

The two sets of speeches that are presented individually by Brutus and Mark Anthony give an indication of how completely opposite they view the death of Caesar and anything else associated to this death. WebBrutus cleverly uses the power of three by asking rhetorical questions relating to freedom, identity, and loyalty. At his funeral he proves many points with just one speech. This helped the characters to express their emotions clearly. Brutus uses them to confuse the people to justify the killing of Caesar. When Brutus, in his speech to the people, says he loved Caesar but loves Rome more, he is being honest. While Antony talks about how it wasnt good for Julius Caesar to die. Antony, on the other hand, despises Brutus for his betrayal of his friend and leader, and in his own speech, he sneers at Brutus's honor until he turns the crowd against Brutus, starting a civil war. After Brutuss speech, the citizens of Rome were all in agreement that Brutus did the right thing for Rome. After Caesar's brutal murder, Brutus a very honourable Roman, who helped in in Caesar's death, and Mark Antony, one of Caesar's closest friends, gave speeches at Caesar's funeral, trying to convince the crowd to agree with them and turn against the other. Mark Antony doesn't have this problem. Instant PDF downloads. O judgment, thou art fled to brutish beasts, And men have lost their reason! Brutus says this to gain empathy from the audience, and acknowledge his love for Rome. Caesar was ambitious to be king which would change Rome from a republic to a monarchy.             Despite these drastic differences, the two orations are similar in a way essential to their effectiveness.  Brutus and Antony demand audience participation by asking questions and making comments they know will spark fire in the hearts of the Roman people.  After providing his explanation for the extermination of a dangerously ambitious tyrant, Brutus questions the people as to whether or not he has offended anyone or if anyone disagrees with his ideals.  He is such an authority figure, though, and he knows no one will stand up to him because the people find safety within the mass.  He dares anyone to defy him, "I pause for a / reply" (Act III, scene ii, lines 34-5).  The people reply, "None, Brutus, none!" Regarding that, Romeo does suffer We use cookies to offer you the best experience. Brutus delivers his speech in a laudatory manner by conveying Caesars deeds and claiming he was ambitious, although Antony contradicts Brutus claims and says Caesar spurned the crown with the intent to merely rule as a de facto dictator. Also, he asks the crowd if he can come down and join them, saying they give him permission, again giving them that sense of authority. For example, Brutus says, Believe me for my honor, and have respect of my honour, that you may believe me (III.ii,15-18). It makes the plebeians think that Brutus was not worthy of this title, and that he ed Csar for no reason other than showing his humbleness to the public. Webwhat are the major differences in brutus and antony's speeches; Call: (201) 991-2002; accor stadium seating; euclid city hall birth certificate; mirabella bunny adams; Search. The way both use this is different but it works to convince the plebeians to believe what they are trying to say. Web1) Brutus has mixed feelings 2) "Why I, that did love Caesar when I struck him" Lesson (2) Which is the best summary of the central idea of this part of Antony's speech? " William Shakespeare, a very famous writer, tells the story of Julius Caesar. WebWhat are the major differences in Brutus and Antony's speeches.pdf. 20 One major element of Julius Caesar is rhetoric the skill of persuading others with words. Brutus is a conspirator, and he has been involved in the death of Caesar. Brutus and Antony both made convincing speeches, but Antony came out on top, because Antony let the people make up their own mind, by appealing to their emotions. Here he uses rhetorical questioning, directed toward the crowd, to show the obvious answer as well disprove Brutuss claim. Latest answer posted February 02, 2021 at 12:00:38 PM. As well as slowly dismantling Brutus.

Proficient in: Roman Empire, Plays, Writers. His speech is very basic, and because the plebeians are so easy to sway, he is able to initially grab hold of their minds. The tone of Brutus' speech is prideful, while the tone of Antony's speech is dramatic and inflammatory. Finally, Brutuss arrogance is apparent in that he takes for granted that Antonys speech will post no threat to him. Antony questions Brutus logic by asking several rhetorical questions like, When the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept: Ambition should be made of sterner stuff: Yet Brutus says he is ambitious; And Brutus is an honorable man. and He hath brought many captives home to Rome Whose ransoms did the general coffers fill. Did this in Caesar seem ambitious? After speaking ill of the conspirators, the crowd was swayed to Antonys side and they decided to hunt down the conspirators. Mark Antony, changed by Caesar's death, rises to power after taking it away from those that killed him. We`ll do boring work for you. Brutus is rational; Antony is fiery and emotional Antony says to the assembled mob, Good friends, sweet friends, let me not stir you up to such a sudden flood of mutiny. Perhaps the most accessible way to compare their personalities is to compare their funeral orations. Although Brutus and Antony both executed effective persuasive speeches, Antonys use of repetition , rhetorical questions, and loaded words made his speech more powerful.Both Brutus and Antony used repetition in their speeches to move their audience. During Caesar's funeral, both Marc Antony and brutus give speeches. Unlike the other characters, Casca speaks in prose instead of in verse, an indication that he adheres to Cynic philosophy, in contrast to Brutuss Stoicism and Cassiuss Epicureanism. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Every teacher of literature should use these translations. Don't use plagiarized sources. In Shakespeares play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, he conveys notions regarding human nature and the ways that power changes and corrupts people; he does this through his characters Brutus, Cassius, and Antony. "Compare and contrast the characters of Brutus and Antony in Julius Caesar." His main purpose when addressing the crowd is to convince them of the fact that Caesar's death was fair and beneficial to Rome, and that no punishment or hate should fall on the conspirators.His The emotional appeal Mark Antony was a friend of Caesar he was more of a party person than the others. Latest answer posted March 27, 2020 at 4:31:49 AM. Marc Antony uses all three appeals in his speech to make a very sturdy argument. The victory leads to Caesar's betrayal by his jealous companions. Brutus is an introverted, solitary philosopher, and his speech to the citizens is totally in character. However, Brutus is proven wrong when Antonys oration manipulates the crowd into a mob thirsty for the blood of the conspirators. They completely demystify Shakespeare. These ways are presented in both their words and [], Shakespeares Caesar in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar is often mistaken as being a tyrant. Was Andrew Jackson a Good President Essay, Womens Role in American Revolution Essay, Why Juveniles Should Not be Tried As Adults Essay, Why Does Sexual Assault Occur in the Army Essay, Why I Want to be a Forensic Scientist Essay, Why Feminine Products Should be Free Essay, Is Healthcare a Right or a Privilege Essay, Characteristics of Effective Counselors Essays, The Tragedy Accompanying Love in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar Essay, The Battle Between Ethics and Politics in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar Essay, Imagery of Butterfly's Effect in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar Essay, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar: What Makes Brutus a Tragic Hero Essay, Julius Caesar. However, Shakespeare pits Mark Antonys speech against Brutus speech. Antonys speech is persuasive, and heartfelt. He understands the Romans unlike Brutus. Brutus speech is brief and not heartfelt. Mark Antony becomes victorious in winning the hearts of the Romans by having his speech be more rhetoric and effective than Brutus speech. The best way to analyse this key speech from the play is to go through it, summarising it section by section. Brutus is the person talking about how it was good for their leader to die. Both characters try to persuade the audience, but they achieve different tones using literary and rhetorical devices. To help the audience see the benefit of Caesar's death Brutus says that with Caesar the people would "die all slaves." These help enhance Marc Antonys speech by persuading the audience towards considering that Caesar was a good man. This view comes from the characterization of Caesar through Cassius and Brutus eyes. In Mark Antonys speech, he sways them to believe that Caesar did not deserve to die, and that the conpirators were the real enemies by using rhetorical devices like rhetorical question and apostrophe. Read both carefully. Marc Antonys eulogy is more compelling to the crowd with his use of rhetorical appeals, ethos, pathos, and logos, compared to Brutus in the tragedy, Julius Caesar. Soon after Caesars death, senators Marc Antony and Brutus spoke on the dramatic death of Caesar using persuasive speeches to gain trust and reliance from the audience. Latest answer posted February 23, 2021 at 11:25:51 AM. In the tragic play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, the ruler of Rome, Julius Caesar, is stabbed to death by some of his so-called friends. You'll be able to access your notes and highlights, make requests, and get updates on new titles. Refine any search. Forgive me for being meek. He is telling them to believe him for his honor and not for the reasons he gives. Nature Structured cf therapy groups o Structured Can be applied on multiple. Antony and Brutus are in many ways alike. Use proper spelling and grammar. The citizens , say, The will the will! Both speakers used ethos, logos, and pathos to persuade the people of Rome. He said that he honored Caesar because he was valiant but slew him because he was ambitious. Our, "Sooo much more helpful thanSparkNotes. Brutus felt he was doing it for the good of Rome. In his play, Marc Antony delivers a powerful speech that uses many different rhetorical devices, appeals, and different styles of writing. This has caused readers to question the [], William Shakespeares early writing aims to advance a philosophy of history. As Caesar was traveling down the roads of Rome, other senators were starting to get nervous about his growing power. Antony also uses ethos and pathos when he says, He was my friend, faithful and just to me. This is ethos in the way it gives him credibility as a friend, suggesting that he would truly know Caesar. To stress his point Brutus uses parallel structure. This is not true because Brutus claims he is honorable when he obviously is not. Yet Brutus says he was ambitious (Shakespear 56). (Act III, scene ii, line 36).  Once he knows he has won the people, Brutus states that he has the same death for himself (the same death as Caesar) when it will benefit Rome.  To this, the people reply with shouts of, Compare And Contrast Brutus And Antony's Speech. In the novel, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by Shakespeare, after Brutus brutally executes Caesar in Act 3 Scene 2, Antony is allowed to give a speech to the people of Rome whom have seen witnessed this fatal tragedy in Scene 3. The conspirators, Brutus and Cassius being the most important, assassinate Julius Caesar and Marcus Antonius, better known as Antony, and Octavius Caesar, Caesar's heir to the thrown, revenge Caesar's. The mob is angry immediately after Brutus' speech but becomes calm by Mark Antony's support of the conspirators. Meanwhile, Caesar tells Antony that he wishes he were surrounded by fat, satisfied men, unlike Cassius, who has a lean and hungry lookthat is, hes dangerous. Yet as his famous speech to the plebs shows, he's already preparing to gain revenge. But in Antonys speech he tells the plebeians, I should do Brutus wrong and Cassius wrong who, you all know, are honorable men. He told the crowd about Caesars will, telling them that they would think twice if they heard what was in the will, but he doesnt read it to them. Because the speeches are long and challenging, it is best to view, re-view, read, and analyze. Each time Antony declares how hhonorable the Brutus and the conspirators are, the phrase accrues an increasingly sarcastic tone until, by the end of the speech, its meaning has been completely inverted. Similarly, each time Antony cites Brutus claim that Caesar was ambitious, the claim loses force and credibility.

'(lines 18-20) Brutus only wanted to try to have the citizens of Rome to understand the sorrow/guilt he was going through, even though he had felt he had killed Caesar for a good reason or for the better of Rome. In Mark Antonys speech, he sways them to believe that Caesar did not deserve to die, and that the conpirators were the real enemies by using rhetorical devices like rhetorical question and apostrophe. Most of the citizens, if not all of them side with Antony and will most likely help him accede to a great title of power in the future and also betray Brutus because of what Antony has them believe, i.e. In his speech he says that Caesar was very determined but was never able to actually give reason as to how or why. But Marc Antony and Brutus speechs were very different. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1713 titles we cover. He reeled in the crowd like a fish and captured them with his compelling diction. Notably, in response, the people praise Brutus himself instead of responding primarily to Brutuss reasoning. Let's fix your grades together!

Students who find writing to be a difficult task. There are several major differences between the two speeches. You have ruined the noblest man, regardless of times. In the play "The Tragedy of Julius Caesar" by Shakespeare, two individuals named Brutus and Antony give a funeral oration to the people of Rome in concern of the justification of Caesars death. WebBrutus cleverly uses the power of three by asking rhetorical questions relating to freedom, identity, and loyalty. This is why Mark Antony gave a better speech than Brutus.